Head to head
OXO Cold Brew Maker vs Toddy Cold Brew System
Head-to-head: OXO Brew Cold Brew Coffee Maker versus Toddy Cold Brew System on filtration, batch size, maintenance, and cup quality.
OXO Brew Cold Brew Coffee Maker
The most engineered immersion brewer, with a rainmaker lid for even saturation.
- Brew method: Immersion
- Filter: Reusable ultra-fine stainless steel mesh
Sources: OXO official product specifications, Major retailer product listings, Published coffee gear reviews
Check current price
Toddy Cold Brew System
The original since 1964, built around reusable felt filters and big batches.
- Brew method: Immersion
- Filter: Reusable felt filters (paper bags optional)
Sources: Toddy official product specifications, Major retailer product listings, Published coffee gear reviews
Check current priceOXO Brew Cold Brew Coffee Maker
What owners report
- Owners praise the Rainmaker shower-head lid distributing water evenly over the grounds for consistent saturation
- Many owners like the reusable ultra-fine stainless steel mesh filter ending ongoing filter purchases
- Owners say the measurement markings on the glass carafe make diluting concentrate to taste simple
- Some owners find the modest batch size suits one or two daily drinkers, not households
- Owners note the tall profile takes meaningful fridge shelf height
- A common complaint is the plastic brew chamber holding coffee oils and needing regular washing
Toddy Cold Brew System
What owners report
- Owners praise the reusable felt filters for a noticeably sediment-free, heavy-bodied concentrate
- Many owners like the large batch yield covering several days of drinking from one steep
- Owners say the simple two-vessel design leaves few parts to clean
- Some owners find the felt filters need rinsing and air-drying after each use to avoid mildew
- Owners note the bulky two-piece setup takes real counter and fridge space
- A common complaint is replacement felt filters being an ongoing cost
Our recommendation
Buy the OXO Brew if you brew for one or two people and want the simplest routine: rinse the steel mesh and you are done. Buy the Toddy if you drink cold brew daily and want the heaviest-bodied, cleanest concentrate in the largest batches. The decision is maintenance tolerance versus batch ambition. For the full ranking, see our best cold brew makers guide, and read the individual OXO review and Toddy review for depth.
Filtration: steel mesh vs felt
The OXO uses a reusable ultra-fine stainless steel mesh filter; the Toddy uses reusable felt filters. Felt filters finer, producing heavier-bodied, more sediment-free concentrate, but felt must be rinsed and fully air-dried after every use to prevent mildew, and replacement felts cost money over time. The OXO's mesh rinses in seconds and never needs replacing, but lets more fine sediment through. This is the central trade of the comparison.
Saturation: rainmaker lid vs manual
The OXO's rainmaker shower-head lid distributes water evenly over the grounds automatically. The Toddy has no distribution aid; you pour and stir manually. Even saturation matters because dry pockets under-extract while wet zones over-extract, so the OXO produces more consistent results for brewers who do not want to fuss.
Batch size and routine
The Toddy is a batch system: one steep produces a large volume of concentrate that covers several days. The OXO makes a modest batch suited to one or two daily drinkers, so heavy drinkers brew more often. If your routine is a pitcher a week, the Toddy wins on convenience; if it is a pitcher every few days, the OXO's smaller footprint is easier to live with.
Separation and cleanup
The OXO's auto-drain separates concentrate from grounds without lifting a heavy, dripping filter. The Toddy drains through felt more slowly and requires handling the filter for its rinse-and-dry routine. The OXO wins on cleanup speed; the Toddy wins on the cup that cleanup produces.
Choose OXO Brew Cold Brew Coffee Maker if…
- You brew for one or two people and want the simplest possible routine
- You dislike consumable filters and maintenance chores
- You value even, consistent extraction without manual stirring
Choose Toddy Cold Brew System if…
- You drink cold brew daily and want maximum batch size
- Concentrate body and clarity are your top priorities
- You do not mind rinsing and drying felt filters after each use
Questions, answered
Which makes better-tasting cold brew, OXO or Toddy?
The Toddy's felt filtration produces heavier-bodied, cleaner concentrate; the OXO's even saturation produces more consistent extraction. Most tasters would call the Toddy's cup richer and the OXO's cup cleaner and more balanced. Preference decides.
Which is easier to clean?
The OXO, clearly: rinse the steel mesh and the auto-drain handles separation. The Toddy's felt filters need thorough rinsing and complete air-drying after every use.
Which is better for a household of cold brew drinkers?
The Toddy: its large batches mean brewing once instead of twice a week. The OXO's modest batch size is built for one or two drinkers.
Do either require buying filters forever?
The OXO's steel mesh is permanent. The Toddy's felt filters are consumable and need periodic replacement, though paper filter bags are an alternative.